Simplemost is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Cotton Potholder

Last updated on October 11, 2021

We looked at the top 13 Cotton Potholders and dug through the reviews from 48 of the most popular review sites including and more. The result is a ranking of the best Cotton Potholders.

Best Cotton Potholder

Our Review Process

Don't Waste Your Money is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to. Learn more.

Look for the Simplemost seal for products that are the best in a category.

Cooking results in delectable meals that delight the taste buds and excite the sense of smell. However, it can also result in painful burns on your hands if you’re not careful. This is why a cotton potholder is such a useful and versatile kitchen item.

Often made out of quilted cotton with several layers, the potholder is used to cover your hands when you’re picking up and moving hot items like pots, pans and casserole dishes. Whether you’re cooking on the stovetop or taking something out of the oven, a potholder makes it easier and safer to complete your tasks.

One potholder covers one hand. In most cases, you’ll need to use two potholders — one for each hand — when handling hot dishes. Even if the dish you’re picking up is light and can be managed with one hand, having the extra potholder ensures you don’t burn your other hand if you accidentally touch the scalding surface of the dish.

Most potholders come in a square shape, which is typically five inches on each side. This way, the potholder is big enough to cover the full hand but small enough so it doesn’t get caught on any handles or hang on to a lit burner.

In addition to helping cooks handle hot pans and dishes, a cotton potholder has several other uses. Depending on the size of the pan and the size of the potholder, it can be used as a trivet. This way, you can protect your table from the hot surface of the pan. Potholders can also act as coasters for any dishes that have moisture on the outside, absorbing the liquid and keeping your table clean. You can also use them as a spoon rest while cooking.

Our Picks For The Top Cotton Potholders

View All Recommendations
Product Overview
Our Take
  Top Pick

DII Machine Washable & Heat Resistant Cotton Potholder, 3-Piece

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

DII

Machine Washable & Heat Resistant Cotton Potholder, 3-Piece

The high-quality terry cloth material, quilting and padding increases the heat resistance of these potholders. They can be used to take hot items out of the oven, or as a trivet to protect your table. They are durable and long-lasting for daily use.

Overall Take

Heat-Resistant Up to 400 DegreesSafely remove baking trays and cast iron pans from the oven with these cotton potholders.

  Runner Up

Odebao Anti-Skid Cotton Potholder, 8-Piece

Odebao

Anti-Skid Cotton Potholder, 8-Piece

These high-quality quilted cotton potholders have corner pockets for your hands. They are extremely flexible and able to withstand high temperatures. Home chefs will appreciate that the potholders are anti-skid to prevent slips and machine washable for easy clean up.

Overall Take

Built-In Hanging LoopThis economical set of cotton potholders comes with a total of eight pieces.

  We Also Like

DII Machine Washable & Heat Resistant 100% Cotton Potholder, 3-Piece

DII

Machine Washable & Heat Resistant Potholder, 3-Piece

The high-quality terry cloth material, quilting and padding increases the heat resistance of these potholders. They can be used to take hot items out of the oven, or as a trivet to protect your table. They are durable and long-lasting for daily use.

Overall Take

Great for CookingSafely remove baking trays and cast iron pans from the oven with these cotton potholders.

  Strong Contender

Jennice House Thread Weave Trivets Pure Cotton Potholders, 3-Piece

Jennice House

Pure Cotton Potholders, 3-Piece

Each one of these round cotton potholders has unique design details sewn in. These are perfect for picking up hot pans or being used as trivets and place mats. They are heat insulated and feature environmentally friendly coloration.

Overall Take

Unique DesignThese woven cotton potholders are accented with hand-sewn details.

  Also Great

Ritz Royale Terry Cloth Collection 100% Cotton Potholder, 2-Pack

Ritz Royale

Terry Cloth Collection Potholder, 2-Piece

The unique material adds an extra layer of heat resistance to these cotton potholders. In addition to handling hot pans and dishes, they can be used like hot pads on the table. Plus, they can be machine washed and tumble dried.

Overall Take

Made from Terry-Looped Cotton These cotton potholders protect your hands better than flat fabric.

Don't just take for granted what one reviewer says. Along with our own experts, Simplemost analyzes the top expert reviews of the leading products and generates a score you can actually trust.
20

Products Considered

We identified the majority of the cotton potholders available to purchase.
13

Products Analyzed

We then selected the leading and most popular products for our team to review.

View All Product Rankings

48

Expert Reviews Included

In addition to our expert reviews, we also incorporate feedback and analysis of some of the most respected sources.

33,560

User Opinions Analyzed

We also incorporate user reviews from the leading retailers including

The Best Bang For Your Buck

Odebao Anti-Skid Cotton Potholder, 8-Piece

Our Total Score

9.8

Our Take

These high-quality quilted cotton potholders have corner pockets for your hands. They are extremely flexible and able to withstand high temperatures. Home chefs will appreciate that the potholders are anti-skid to prevent slips and machine washable for easy clean up.

What to Look For

  • One of the most important things to look for in your cotton potholder is the construction. The way the potholder is made will affect the amount of heat resistance the product provides. Some varieties of cotton potholders are woven in several layers, adding a sturdy thickness to the material and making them heat resistant. Others have heat-resistant material in between layers of cotton, adding further protection.
  • Flexibility is a key element to look for in your cotton potholder. Make sure that the material provides enough bend and movement so you can curve the potholder around the dish you’re carrying. If the material is too stiff or has too many layers, you may have difficulty picking up the pan and could end up burning your skin.
  • Potholders are a great way to add a pop of color in your kitchen. They are available in many different styles and colors. Look for one that matches your kitchen décor, or one that adds an accent color to catch the eye.
  • While potholders are not oven mitts, you can actually find some that have a fabric pocket to slip your hand into like a glove. This makes it easier to handle hot dishes, particularly heavy ones or those that are oddly shaped.
  • It’s important that cotton potholders be easy to clean. Since they are used around food, it’s likely they are going to see a lot of spills and drips. As a result, look for cotton potholders that are machine washable. This makes cleanup a breeze. If they are not machine washable, opt for one that can be easily wiped down with a wet cloth.
  • If storage is scarce in your home, you may want to look for a cotton potholder that has hanging loops. That way, you can affix hooks to your cabinets and hang your potholders while they are not in use.

More to explore