Simplemost is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Gift Box

Last updated on November 8, 2019

We looked at the top 10 Gift Boxes and dug through the reviews from 3 of the most popular review sites including Atoya Reviews, Real Simple and more. The result is a ranking of the best Gift Boxes.

Why Trust The Simplemost Score?

Simplemost is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.

Look for the Simplemost seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Gift Boxes

Show Contents
Our Take
  Best to Personalize

MESHA

Gift Boxes, 10 pack

Overall Take

Five-Star BoxesThese all-white MESHA Gift Boxes, 10 pack are easily personalized for weddings, birthdays or Christmas gifts.

  Upgrade Pick

ZMYBCPACK

Luxury Large Black Gift Boxes, 5 pack

Overall Take

Sleek And ElegantOne of the higher end gift boxes on the market, thes ZMYBCPACK Luxury boxes are made out of a heavy cardboard and feature a magnetic closure.

  Best for Color

Chilly

Decorative Gift Boxes, 12 pack

Overall Take

Multiple Color OptionsThis Chilly Decorative Gift Boxes, 12 pack set comes in four fun colors and has a delightful pink ribbon to secure your precious offering inside.

  Best for Mailing

Hallmark

Square Gift Boxes, 5 pack

Overall Take

Perfect for MailingIf you're looking for a reliable Hallmark Square Gift Boxes, 5 pack that can be mailed to a friend or loved one, this set is your best bet.

Don't just take for granted what one reviewer says. Along with our own experts, Simplemost analyzes the top expert reviews of the leading products and generates a score you can actually trust.
17

Products Considered

We identified the majority of the gift boxes available to purchase.
10

Products Analyzed

We then selected the leading and most popular products for our team to review.

View All Product Rankings

3

Expert Reviews Included

In addition to our expert reviews, we also incorporate feedback and analysis of some of the most respected sources.

2,358

User Opinions Analyzed

We also incorporate user reviews from the leading retailers including Amazon and 3 others.

The Best Overall

MESHA Gift Boxes, 10 pack

Our Expert Score
0.0
0 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.2
314 user reviews
Our Take

In addition to being one of the top gift boxes on the market, the MESHA Gift Boxes, 10 pack is also one of the most affordable. The boxes are simple to assemble and perfect for everything from storing paperclips to giving a gift to your bridesmaids. Since the boxes are all-white, they are a blank canvas ready for your personal touches. Gift-givers can add a twine or bow or even decorate the boxes with stamps or stencils.


Our Findings

MESHA Gift Boxes, 10 pack

What We Liked: In addition to being one of the top gift boxes on the market, the MESHA Gift Boxes, 10 pack is also one of the most affordable. The boxes are simple to assemble and perfect for everything from storing paperclips to giving a gift to your bridesmaids. Since the boxes are all-white, they are a blank canvas ready for your personal touches. Gift-givers can add a twine or bow or even decorate the boxes with stamps or stencils.

Simplemost Media

ZMYBCPACK Luxury Large Black Gift Boxes, 5 pack

What We Liked: If you’re searching for elegant gift boxes, the ZMYBCPACK Luxury Large Black Gift Boxes, 5 pack is your best bet. The boxes are made from a quality cardboard that is also eco-friendly and recyclable. There’s also a magnetic closure for ease of use. You can fill the boxes with important documents, memorabilia or gifts for friends or loved ones.

Simplemost Media

Chilly Decorative Gift Boxes, 12 pack

What We Liked: Cute and versatile are the best words to describe the Chilly Decorative Gift Boxes, 12 pack. Each set comes with  yellow, pink, blue and brown boxes that are perfect for gifting tasty treats, baby shower items, jewelry or stocking stuffers. There’s also a stylish pink ribbon to secure the box and give it that decorative touch.

Simplemost Media

Hallmark Square Gift Boxes, 5 pack

Best for Mailing

Hallmark 8" Gift Boxes (Pack of 5; Square Kraft) for Holidays, Birthdays, Crafts and More (Kitchen)


List Price: $7.99 USD
New From: $7.99 USD In Stock
Used from: $7.99 USD In Stock

What We Liked: The Hallmark Square Gift Boxes, 5 pack is made using uniquely sourced materials from well-managed forests. Designed to hold everything from toys to cookies, these boxes can be delivered to the recipient in person or via the postal service. Gift givers can also toss a bow or ribbon on top of the boxes for added color.

Our Gift Box Buying Guide

Not all presents can be neatly wrapped without first being placed in a container. That’s where gift boxes come in. This handy invention not only makes it a cinch to package up homemade baked goods, jewelry, clothing and children’s toys, but it also adds a decorative touch to the gift. While shopping for a set of gift boxes, there are a few things you’ll want to keep in mind.

Simplemost Media

Take a look at the size of your gift to determine what size box to purchase. You’ll find a wide variety of gift boxes on the market, including small boxes that measure 8 x 8 x 4 inches and large boxes that measure 14 x 9.5 x 4.5 inches.

Check the material the gift box is made out of. Though most are made from cardboard, there are thinner boxes that are perfect for lighter items, such as cookies and Christmas ornaments, and thicker boxes suitable for heavier items, like toys and bottles of wine. The Hallmark Square Gift Boxes, 5 pack is made from materials that were sourced from a well-managed forest, and as a result, they fall in between the thin and thick boxes.

Simplemost Media

Make sure the boxes are easy to assemble. This is especially important if you have a large number of boxes to put together, such as for your child’s classmates on Halloween or your bridal party the night before a wedding. It’s also helpful if the boxes can be flattened for storage.

Simplemost Media

Decide what color you’d like your gift set to come in. The MESHA Gift Boxes, 10 pack comes in all white, while the Chilly Decorative Gift Boxes, 12 pack features yellow, pink, blue and brown options. You can also get sets that come strictly in brown or black.

Simplemost Media

Look for any extras that the gift box sets may offer that set them apart from the rest. The ZMYBCPACK Luxury Large Black Gift Boxes, 5 pack, for example, has a magnetic closure. Other sets come with a decorative ribbon closure instead.

Simplemost Fun Fact

Most gift boxes are made from cardboard, which was first invented in 1817 by Sir Malcolm Thornhill. It wasn’t until approximately 60 years later that pre-cut cardboard boxes were created. Companies like Nabisco and Kelloggs took advantage of this handy new packaging for their food products. It wouldn’t take long after that for foldable gift boxes to make their appearance.

Speaking of gifts, the top three most common gifts given at Christmas time are gift cards, electronics and clothing. Since 54% of people return a gift that they have received, it makes sense that gift cards are the preferred present during the holidays.

Another fun fact that you may not be aware of: The largest gift ever given was from France to the United States. It was the Statue of Liberty.

The Gift Box Tips and Advice

  • Make sure the company offers a money back guarantee in case the gift boxes come damaged or do not live up to the claims made in the product description.
  • Consider dressing the gift boxes up. You can use gel pens or paints to add a saying or design to the box. You can also decorate the box with bows, ribbons or twine. Additional options for adding some flair to your package: decoupage, applying washi tape and using stencils.
  • You don’t just have to use the boxes for gift giving. They also work great to help organize various spaces in your home. For example, you can use them in your office to hold paperclips, in your laundry room to hold thread, needles and extra buttons or in your pantry to store snacks.
  • If your gift boxes are made of cardboard, you’ll want to recycle them when they’ve outgrown their usefulness. Just remember to remove any plastic or metal components, as well as any decorations. Then fold or flatten the box before placing it in your paper recycling bin.
  • Once you find a few gift box sets that you’re interested in buying, you’ll need to compare prices. To do this, you must take into consideration the size of the boxes and the number of boxes within the set. So, you can expect the Hallmark Square Gift Boxes, 5 pack to be cheaper than the MESHA Gift Boxes, 10 pack because it contains less boxes. The Chilly Decorative Gift Boxes, 12 pack is slightly more as well, as it offers the most boxes per set. Then there’s the ZMYBCPACK Luxury Large Black Gift Boxes, 5 pack, which is the most expensive. Though the set only contains five gift boxes, each features quality construction, a larger size and an added magnetic closure.

About The Author

Alicia Bodine
Alicia Bodine 

Alicia Bodine is a New Jersey-based writer specializing in gardening. She enjoys spending time learning about the latest gadgets that make designing, planting and maintaining a garden a breeze. With more than 15 years of experience, her work has appeared in sites like GardenGuides and eHow Garden.